Oneness: An Economics Perspective
(From a
Multi-Essay Series)
Essay Topic: Competitive Capitalism
By Vince Milum, J.D., MBA, CPCU, ARM, AIC, AMIM, ASLI
"Capitalism" is an economic system wherein the
"means of production" are privately owned. The counterpart to
capitalism, variously known as "communism" or "socialism,"
is an economic system where the means of production are publicly owned. This
latter economic order was once trumpeted as being more egalitarian and, thus,
the inevitable course of "industrial" democracies.
But a funny thing happened on the way to the forum …
The industrial revolution has begun to give way to a post-industrial
society. Factory workers are being transformed into "information
specialists" and those who remain in the industrial sector are becoming
skilled technicians. The proletariat that Marx was relying upon to carry out
his revolution are now better educated than he was and are embracing the
materialism of the bourgeois class(es) he so despised.
So, capitalism is the answer to all humanity’s problems,
right? Well, hardly. It’s just that it happens to be the reality for the
time being and for the foreseeable future. So long as the benefits of a market
economy exceed the pitfalls, capitalism is here to stay. But pitfalls there
are and they need to be routinely addressed.
One of the major pitfalls of capitalism is the
all-too-frequent market domination by one party or a select group of parties.
Another and often related pitfall is inadequate or incorrect information.
For a fully-functioning market economy, there must be (a)
many buyers and many sellers (with no single buyer or seller being able to
significantly influence price), (b) ease of entry into and exit from the
marketplace, (c) a homogeneous mechanism for evaluating products and services,
and (d) a perfect flow of information. Whenever any of these conditions is not
present, then Oneness economic institutions must be prepared to act.
Many buyers and sellers.
If we want to avoid being subjected to the whims (pricing
and otherwise) of unresponsive monopolies, then we consumers must be willing
to support smaller, independent businesses which are responsive to our
demands. An example of sustaining consumer choice is patronizing
establishments owned and operated by a resident entrepreneur. Failing to do
this can result in a monolithic environment devoid of customer service.
Similarly, when we are sellers, we should look to diversify
our customer base so as not to subject ourselves and our employees to the
extreme volatility of having to rely upon the purchasing habits of one (or
just a few) customer(s).
Ease of entry and/or exit.
Many potential buyers and/or sellers are discouraged from
participating in the marketplace when there are barriers to their entering the
market or leaving the market. While this topic may be too abstract for some,
one recent innovation helps to illustrate it. The Internet is now helping to
bring market participants together through electronic auctions. This is one
means of ensuring that assets (of various sorts) become fungible and, thus,
encouraging more market participants.
Homogeneous mechanism for evaluating products and services.
In order to fairly compare products and services and,
hence, to gauge relative value(s), we must have a homogenous pricing
mechanism. One version of this mechanism in the marketplace is the unit
pricing of food items at the grocery store (e.g., where one compares the
relative price of a can of food based on a fixed unit of measure). Another is
evaluating the measured watts of output of a stereo unit against a fixed level
of total harmonic distortion (THD). When industry fails to provide this
comparison information, Oneness institutions — government or otherwise —
should intervene.
Perfect flow of information.
In conjunction with our previous topics, there must be a
perfect flow of information so that buyers and sellers can make intelligent
and informed decisions. Once again, the Internet is a vehicle for satisfying
this requirement. One example would be searching for information regarding
infant car seats. In addition to the usual pricing information, one can use
the Internet to find the most up-to-date information regarding recent safety
tests and/or product recalls. Without such information, one might purchase an
inferior and potentially unsafe product.
Conclusion.
With the growing acceptance of the market mechanism as the
preferred allocator of resources, Oneness institutions are now called upon to
ensure the efficiency of the market. As discussed in another article, where
the market fails to satisfy the basic "needs" of our citizens, a
social safety-net is in order.